What Makeup Artists Think of the Top Readers’ Choice 2026 Makeup Winners

When it comes to beauty pros, the average beauty lover arguably has the most in common with makeup artists. Think about it: You may be applying skin-care products, but you’re not administering high-tech treatments like a dermatologist does daily; you may give yourself twice-weekly blowouts and even occasionally trim your bangs, but you’re not crafting cuts and mixing color like a hairstylist does every day. But on a daily basis, you are your own makeup artist. The products you pick over and over are crucial to your look, just like the products makeup artists keep in their kits have proven themselves to be the best for their clients and themselves.

And it turns out that a lot of the makeup you love—enough to win 2026 Allure Readers’ Choice Awards—overlap quite a bit with professional makeup artists’ favorites.

We chatted with Vincent Oquendo, Jamie Greenberg, and Kelsey Deenihan—whose gorgeous makeup mastery you’ve seen on celebrities like Jenna Ortega, Rashida Jones, and Hilary Duff, respectively—to find out which of this year’s Readers’ Choice Award winners they would have voted for, too. These are the nine that you have in common with the pros.

Click through to see if your favorite skin, hair, makeup, and body products were voted most-loved in the 2026 Readers’ Choice Awards. Then, read their reviews.

See All the Expert Recommendations

Tool

Beautyblender Original Makeup Sponge

It should come as no surprise that a lot of makeup artists are true to the original Beautyblend sponge, including Jamie Greenberg, makeup artist and founder of Jamie Makeup. The Beautyblender changed makeup application forever,” she tells Allure. “I still use it constantly because nothing presses foundation into the skin in a way that looks as natural and skin-like. It gives you that expensive-looking finish where you can’t tell where the makeup ends and the skin begins.”

Foundation

Haus Labs Triclone Skin Tech Foundation

Speaking of foundation, you’ll often find Greenberg using Haus Labs Triclone Skin Tech Foundation because it photographs flawlessly and wears beautifully on mature skin. “This foundation is gorgeous because it gives coverage without killing the life of the skin,” she says of the buildable, arnica-infused formula. “It has that modern finish people want right now—polished but still breathable and real.”

Clean Foundation

Merit The Minimalist Perfecting Complexion Stick

When she isn’t using it on clients who want their skin to look like skin, makeup artist and Tinge artistry advisor Kelsey Deenihan is using Merit The Minimalist Perfecting Complexion Stick on herself. “It’s such an easy product for creating fresh, natural-looking skin,” she says, raving about its ability to even out the complexion while still letting natural texture and dimension come through. “I rarely swipe it directly all over the face. I like to apply it strategically around redness, the center of the face, or anywhere that needs evening out, then blend with fingers or a dense brush for the most natural finish.”

Concealer

Nars Radiant Creamy Concealer

“It’s been a longtime favorite for a reason,” Deenihan says, pointing out Nars Radiant Creamy Concealer’s luminous skin-like coverage and layerability sans heaviness or dryness. “Less is usually more,” she tells Allure. “I like placing it more toward the inner corner and around areas of discoloration rather than doing a huge triangle under the eyes.” Another pro tip: Let it sit for a few seconds before blending to get a little extra coverage without needing more product.

Clean Concealer

Kosas Revealer Concealer

Kosas Revealer Concealer earned a spot in the Readers’ Choice Awards Hall of Fame this year, but it’s been in Greenberg’s kit for a while. “Kosas really nailed the balance between makeup and skincare, and this concealer embodies that,” she says. “It brightens without looking heavy, dry, or cakey—the dream—and I especially love it for undereyes because it doesn’t settle.”

Eye Shadow

Makeup by Mario Master Mattes Eyeshadow Palette: The Neutrals

Makeup artist Vincent Oquendo says he can create any kind of look with Makeup by Mario Master Mattes Eyeshadow Palette: The Neutrals, and Deenihan seconds that. “It’s one of those palettes I reach for constantly because the tones are so balanced and wearable, she says. “It’s a staple for everything from soft everyday glam to more sculpted, editorial looks.”